First, NY Times writer Jayson Blair plagiarized. Then A Million Pieces writer James Frey who said the work was nonfiction when it was fiction. Dan Brown’s The DaVinci Code is under suspicion. Now How Opal Mehta Got Kissed, Got Wild, and Got a Life by Kaavya Viswanathan has passages from two books by Megan McCafferty.
The last thing I want to do as a writer is plagiarize. As I read resource after resource, I fear that some resource’s words or phrases will stick in my head and I will have thought they’re my own rather than something that hid in a tiny forgotten memory box somewhere in the brain.
I don’t want to steal someone’s ideas and pass them as my own. It feels wrong and I’ll feel guilty for days, months, and possibly years. The cases of Blair and James Frey are obvious. But could Brown and Viswanathan have memorized facts they didn’t realize they had? Brown’s case is a tough one because he intermingles history with fiction.
I’m beginning to question ideas that pop in my head. Are they there because of something I experienced? Or are they there simply because my creative mind put some experiences together and created a new one?
I wrote a tutorial and posted it in an online resource. Shortly after, I received an email from someone who had an article on the topic somewhere else online. When I wrote the tutorial, I based it on my experience and then I researched many resources to tweak it further — one of which was the person contacting me. I felt horrible when I got her email.
I looked at my content and hers. There were some similarities, but some of it I came up with on my own or did I? Could I have read her tutorial months before? Stupidly, I should’ve referred to her tutorial and a couple of others when I published mine. Sometimes I get so wrapped up in my writing that I forget to add the important resources as I believe linking to others is vital.
Yesterday’s post provides a good reason not to plagiarize non-fiction — the story might have inaccurate facts.
Denny Hatch wrote a great article on plagiarism.
Here are plagiarism resources:
Subscribe:

2 comments
[...] I’ve written on this topic before and wonder if perhaps some writers truly thought their ideas were original — when it was an old memory stored in the back of their minds? If you can’t connect a memory to a previously read story or article, you naturally think it’s your own imagination. [...]
What an excellent reason for sticking to the classics for your reading excursions–and then writing about your personal applications to your own life. I, at the moment, am most interested in what is being taught and written at the AU School of Business (are we always supposed to add “Kogod”?) about personal business ethics. How do they play into the social responsibility of business? Is it ethical for a CEO to ask for (demand?) remuneration which is clearly excessive? Is corporate management responsible for more than just getting a product out the door at the highest possible price? What do you think about the current disinclination on the part of the domestic drug businesses to develop any new anti-biotics? (The argument reported in the Wall Street Journal is that they are not very profitable.) I wonder how the CEO who made such a decision (”forget any new antibiotics”) would feel if a member of his or her family developed MRSR (which is currently non-responsive to 10 to the 12 classes of antibiotics), and found that it was now resistent to all of the current antibiotics. Developing a new answer could not occur quickly enough to save the life of the person affected as some things simply cannot be rushed.
Where is AU going in its consideration of these types of challenges?
Post a comment (or leave a trackback)